I think that listening to you doctor's or a nurse's or an anticoagulation clinic tech's recommendations, ignoring them, and doing what you learn here or from a dosing chart is doing a disservice to all this person's patients who actually do what they're told. If you are doing something different, and bring your INRs into range, you MUST tell the caregiver how you did it. Otherwise, they'll continue blindly dispensing potentially fatal advice.
Mark you yourself are new to this and have yet to self test. While what your saying makes perfectly honest sense, in the real world, it can have very harmful effects.
Follow the Chain of Command rules apply here.
Cardiologist or other is the commanding General
Coumadin manager is second in command
Patient is expected to follow and carry out those orders. even if it means sacrificing their lives.
To present to the second in command that you may possess skills better then theirs, is a slap in the face and equivelant to striking an officer. What happens now? Your court martialed. Big Red Flag in patients record saying "NONCOMPLIANT" or "RENEGADE." Recommendation=Discharge.
Now this patient has to find someone else to manage their care and for some, that may be a blessing, but for most, it leads to yet another incompetent manager and the cycle is repeated.
I'm not condoning that anyone deviate from their managers instructions, unless they are proving imcompetent, then they must take the bull by the horns and take matters into their own hands for their own personal safety.
I tried this very thing with my first clinic. Even being diplomatic and making simple suggestions caused an all out nuclear war. I got fed up. I presented my documention on how and what I did vs what they told me to do, to bring myself in range when they had already stuck my veins repeatedly for 2 months and I still wasn't doing anything but see sawing up and down. There was no middle ground or even the hint of understanding. It was their way or no way.
The funny thing about this whole episode was when I presented some of Al Lodwicks information and it still didn't matter to them in the least. I switched clinics and started going to my Cardiologists clinics instead, because they used fingerstick testing.
Guess what? This very same nurse had quit her job at the old clinic and was now at the new. We both sort of just eyeballed each other for a minute, then she broke out with a smile and apologized to me for all that she had put me through before. She explained to me that she was following a protocol that was made by one of that clinics "Experts". She never realized how wrong that "Expert" was. On her desk was just about every article from Al Lodwicks site in a binder. She too, had seen the light and was now doing the same thing we are trying to teach people here. She has been doing an excellent job ever since. In fact, she's the one that signed off on my home testing. I had to demonstrate to her that I could perform the test on myself and get reliable results. We've been good friends ever since.
For her at the other clinic, it was pure hell. She wasn't sure what she was doing was right, but that's what the doctors told her to do. She said that even though I disobeyed her and took matters into my own hands, then provided proof of what I'd done, it just blew her away.
It's true, anyone can home test, but not everyone is capable of self dosing. For those that can, (and may have too) we are simply trying to teach you what those managers should have known all along.