I've contemplated for days, staying or leaving this site.
After careful review of my feelings, I've decided that leaving serves no purpose.
Nothing has changed about this site. Not one thing. There are still cliques, PM undergrounding, and other assorted stuff going on that will never change. Every forum has them. It will all continue whether or not I stay or leave. The only thing different would be that you'd be missing another member.
There are 1500+ thinking, breathing, brainy people here. Every single one of you thinks differently on the same issues. It's impossible to take any action or lack of action, without it resulting in negative consequences each and every time. No matter what is done, someone is unhappy.
I've been blamed for starting the HCR thread. I did not. I merely got trapped as the first poster when the old server went down on July 14TH. I've been accused of using the thumbs up icon as if to say, "The thread is back up and running, now we can continue" like I'm thumbing my nose at those that do not wish to participate in it nor agree with it. I don't pay attention to icons. I do not pay attention to post counts. I look at posts,post content, persons medical histories and the like. I never even realized there was a thumbs up icon and regardless, that is how the thread was started by the originator. The debate going on was semi decent until someone complained to the owner and the WAR room got created, then it all went south. Personal attacks, thread crapping, everything possible to get it shut down. Since those attempts have failed, some people decide to protest that by leaving. The HCR thread is no different then the valve wars that have ensued. When people don't like them, they don't participate in them, so why is it that we have to have such a ruckus over the HCR thread? May I remind all of you that while your active participants in the forums and you feel as though you have ownership of it, you are guests in the owners forum and you are only guests.
What I can not figure out to this minute is, if a forum has a warning posted on it that says "If you don't want your feathers ruffled DO NOT ENTER" and people still go into it, KNOWINGLY,then get their feathers ruffled, get mad and leave. You were warned not to go there to begin with, so who's fault is it?
Not long ago, the same tactics were used against the owners judgment on the issue of a certain member. What you don't know is that this forum was within a mouse click away of not being here for anyone. It came very close to not having a small talk forum either. I've been sitting back and watching. I figure if I'm not posting, then there shouldn't be any problem, but the problems still continue regardless. There is only one thread that some of you have a real problem with and you've already been told if you don't like it, stay out of it. It can't be any clearer then that. Why must the whole forum come to a grinding halt, with people leaving, because a few people don't like it?
There's nitpicking, armchair moderating and all sorts of destructive behavior going on right here in small talk. Do you really want to see the Joke thread, photo's threads, Throw downs and all other non heart related matters destroyed? Is that what would make you happy? Purely a heart talk forum with absolutely no deviation? No more joking in ANY thread at any time? I don't know about you, but if I want to be bored to death, I can just go to the Doctors office and get that.
My only concern, from day one, was for this forum to become the greatest support site for valve replacement surgery. I hope that all of you share that vision also. Can we cut the destructive behavior and become constructive and productive? Stop this silliness of reading into things that are not there, stop this lawyer ball thing with every single word a person posts, stop all the childish behavior in general?
I think it's pretty bad when I can post "Good Morning" and someone goes into auto tuning mode and decides that because I said "Good Morning" I have malicious intent behind it. Yes, it's that bad! It's gone on so long that it's actually got me doing the same thing and now I've become defensive. No one should be feeling like this. There is no reason for it. Some of you are complaining that just having HCR/WAR room thread/forum here is stressful and I'm telling you some of the actions being taken by some members around here are more stressful then any thread/forum could be.
We've made a lot of progress in bettering the site, but there is still a lot more that can be done. Could we possibly WORK TOGETHER to make that an achievable goal? Peacefully, productively and harmoniously? There are going to be times when things get discussed and a heated debate ensues. Do all of them have to turn into something ugly or is it possible to be respectful to one another and debate it in a civil manor, without insults and personal attacks and done in an adult manor?
I came to this forum in December of 2001, a scared person about to face another OHS just like the rest of you. If it were not for the members at that time, there is no doubt in my mind that I would not have made it. I had the wind in my sails knocked out of me but good from the surgery and was deeply depressed. So much so, that it was affecting my recovery. My son printed off everything you had to say to me and brought it to me. Listening to you, I was able to pull myself out of the dirt and start shaking it off. I'm forever indebted to you for that. For that reason, that is why I have stayed here. To help others that will go in and no doubt, some will be on the brink of death, and it's then that I hope to make the same difference to them, as you did for me.
I've cried with you, laughed with you, celebrated with you, shared with you, 9 years of my life. You are my family. I hate to think that there are a couple of family members that would rather cause problems in the family, then to allow the family unit to exist as one.