I posted a couple of weeks ago about this. I tried creams and also an Rx cortisone tape post-surgery and none of it did anything but irritate my skin. At just over 6 months post-op I had a cortisone shot in the keloid (raised) portion of my scar that did the trick as far as flattening it. For the redness I am going to start laser therapy next month, which will take a few treatments over a period of time. Some people's fade over time to where they aren't very noticeable, you just have to wait and see how your skin reacts. As I said the creams didn't work for me, but maybe they do for others.