Reasonable charge for an echocardiogram + color 2-D doppler

Valve Replacement Forums

Help Support Valve Replacement Forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
P

PapaHappyStar

I just recieved the bill for my first echo procedure from the hospital, it is around $3000. I wanted to find out if this sounded reasonable. I have to pay 20% of this since I wasnt covered at the 100% level then.

It sounds unreasonable that the echo should cost as much as the cath.
 
I think the charge sounds outrageous. I have my echos done in the cardio's offiice and I think the charge is around $450. I am sure a hospital would charge more due to overhead but this seems unreasonable to me.
Good luck,
Gina
 
That is an unreasonable charge if my recollection is right. My cardio's office charges $1,400, I believe, and the hospital $1,800. The cardio's lab does a better job, too.

Ask them how much of your anatomy they turned to gold with their "magic" sound waves...

Best wishes,
 
I had an echo last month (10/7). Just checked my insurer's website. Bill from cardio was for $1,236 (which included $80 OV). Diagnostics were $565, $346 and $245. Insurance paid $290.11, $129.99 and $153.21, respectively. Billing didn't break out what each charge was for.

My co-pay is $30. No deductible (next year another story, though).

My cardio's office is attached to Baylor Medical Center near downtown Dallas.
 
I got a bill once for one of mine (usually they're fully covered by my insurance minus $15 co-pay unless my referal has run out) and seem to recall it being around the $700 range. I don't remember how extensive it was.


$3000 is definitely high and should be investigated some.
 
This was at Provena Mercy Center in Aurora, IL. They billed the insurance a total of $2851 for the echo -- broke it into 3 pieces -- for M-Mode, 2-D and Doppler I think -- the insurance ( Aetna Open Choice PPO ) after discount, co-pay and deductible paid $946.88. This bill does not include the amount charged by the interpreting physician -- another $351.

I talked with the hospital over the phone, they claim that a national regulatory agency reviews their charges for the procedure.

What really hits the fan is their echo was probably a bad misreading, both the interpreting cardiologist and the echo tech made errors. The diagnosis on the report was, Moderate AS with no mention of regurgitation and annular calcification of the mitral valve. I had the echo video checked by another cardiologist who thought he saw moderate AI as well, finally I had another echo done at NY presbyterian which showed severe AS , mild AI and no problems with the mitral valve. At NYP they checked the gradients across the aortic valve with a cath subsequently and the second echo appears to be a lot closer to the cath result.

I am going to pursue this with Mercy Hospital -- they have to explain satisfactorily why they seem to be charging atleast twice as much as everyone else especially since their services were subpar at best and life threatening at worst.

Burair
 
My echo done at the doctor office in September is Echo Trnsthorac Real-time.com $450, Doppler Echo Cont Wave: complt. $350, and Doppler echo Color Flow Velocit $230. The total of $1,030. Doctor visit the following week for results $125. My past stress echoes are around 1,170.
 
I have Aetna HMO and with my $1,030 echo, Aetna contract adjustment was $503.87 and they paid $496.13 and my co pay was $30. Aetna was given a $503.87 discount for their contract adjustment.
 
Back
Top