From the New York Times 7/20/04, via AOL:
Kirk Condyles for The New York Times
Dr. Mark A. Goodman of Garden City, N.Y., has tested all his patients and found many are aspirin resistant.
For Some, Aspirin May Not Help Hearts
By ANDREW POLLACK
Published: July 20, 2004
More than 20 million Americans take aspirin regularly to help prevent heart attacks and strokes. But new evidence suggests that for many of them, the pills do little if any good. Recent studies have found that anywhere from 5 percent to more than 40 percent of aspirin users are "nonresponsive" or "resistant" to the medicine. That means that aspirin does not inhibit their blood from clotting, as it is supposed to.
"They are taking it for stroke and heart attack prevention, and it's not going to work," said Dr. Daniel I. Simon, the associate director of interventional cardiology at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston and an associate professor at Harvard.
A vast majority of doctors do not test patients for aspirin resistance. Several doctors said even resistant patients would probably still be better off taking aspirin than dropping it. Also, people who use aspirin to fight pain or inflammation are not affected by the new findings.
Scientists are racing to clarify further the significance of aspirin resistance and how to counteract it. What they learn could influence how one of the oldest and most widely consumed medicines is used, perhaps leading to more customized therapies.
"You're talking about a huge number of people" who might not be benefiting, said Dr. Michael J. Domanski, head of the clinical trials unit of the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute.
Although some experts have known about aspirin resistance for years, it is a topic of growing interest as studies have confirmed that aspirin takers who are resistant have a higher rate of heart attacks and strokes than nonresistant aspirin users.
"Aspirin resistance is associated with a worse outcome,"' Dr. Deepak L. Bhatt, director of the interventional cardiology fellowship program at the Cleveland Clinic, said. "The literature is pretty consistent about that."
New tests make it far easier than in the past to measure response to aspirin. Companies selling such tests are calling attention to aspirin resistance to help in their marketing.
Some experts caution that not enough is understood about the meaning of resistance to justify routine tests. Moreover, the experts say, it is unclear what to do for aspirin-resistant patients. Should aspirin be dropped? Should the doses be increased? Should patients be switched to other anticlotting drugs?
"For none of these tests is there evidence that altering treatment is beneficial to the patient," said Dr. Alan D. Michelson, director of the center for platelet function studies at the University of Massachusetts. "I don't think doctors should do these tests, and I don't think they should change treatments based on these tests."
A small but growing number of doctors are starting to test patients. They argue that even without conclusive evidence it is reasonable to alter therapy rather than have a patient continue to take a drug that a test shows is ineffective.
Dr. Mark A. Goodman, president of Cardiovascular Medical Associates in Garden City, N.Y., said he tested all his patients and found that 20 to 25 percent were aspirin resistant. For those people, Dr. Goodman said, he first tries a higher dose, because that is the least expensive alternative.
If that does not work - and it usually does not - he prescribes another anticlotting drug, Plavix, that can cost $3 or more a day, compared with pennies a day for aspirin.
Aspirin resistance could be one reason many people continue to have heart attacks and strokes even though they take aspirin. But, experts said, it is quite likely that some people have heart attacks or strokes even if aspirin is providing the desired anticlotting effect.
It is widely believed that the main way aspirin provides cardiovascular protection is by blocking the ability of platelets in the blood to stick together, a vital step in forming clots that can lead to a heart attack or stroke. Aspirin blocks an enzyme, cyclo-oxygenase, that is involved in producing thromboxane, a substance that induces platelets to clump.
The standard test of how readily platelets clump is called aggregometry. It is usually performed in a specialized laboratory and can take two to three hours.
Kirk Condyles for The New York Times
Dr. Mark A. Goodman of Garden City, N.Y., has tested all his patients and found many are aspirin resistant.
For Some, Aspirin May Not Help Hearts
By ANDREW POLLACK
Published: July 20, 2004
More than 20 million Americans take aspirin regularly to help prevent heart attacks and strokes. But new evidence suggests that for many of them, the pills do little if any good. Recent studies have found that anywhere from 5 percent to more than 40 percent of aspirin users are "nonresponsive" or "resistant" to the medicine. That means that aspirin does not inhibit their blood from clotting, as it is supposed to.
"They are taking it for stroke and heart attack prevention, and it's not going to work," said Dr. Daniel I. Simon, the associate director of interventional cardiology at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston and an associate professor at Harvard.
A vast majority of doctors do not test patients for aspirin resistance. Several doctors said even resistant patients would probably still be better off taking aspirin than dropping it. Also, people who use aspirin to fight pain or inflammation are not affected by the new findings.
Scientists are racing to clarify further the significance of aspirin resistance and how to counteract it. What they learn could influence how one of the oldest and most widely consumed medicines is used, perhaps leading to more customized therapies.
"You're talking about a huge number of people" who might not be benefiting, said Dr. Michael J. Domanski, head of the clinical trials unit of the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute.
Although some experts have known about aspirin resistance for years, it is a topic of growing interest as studies have confirmed that aspirin takers who are resistant have a higher rate of heart attacks and strokes than nonresistant aspirin users.
"Aspirin resistance is associated with a worse outcome,"' Dr. Deepak L. Bhatt, director of the interventional cardiology fellowship program at the Cleveland Clinic, said. "The literature is pretty consistent about that."
New tests make it far easier than in the past to measure response to aspirin. Companies selling such tests are calling attention to aspirin resistance to help in their marketing.
Some experts caution that not enough is understood about the meaning of resistance to justify routine tests. Moreover, the experts say, it is unclear what to do for aspirin-resistant patients. Should aspirin be dropped? Should the doses be increased? Should patients be switched to other anticlotting drugs?
"For none of these tests is there evidence that altering treatment is beneficial to the patient," said Dr. Alan D. Michelson, director of the center for platelet function studies at the University of Massachusetts. "I don't think doctors should do these tests, and I don't think they should change treatments based on these tests."
A small but growing number of doctors are starting to test patients. They argue that even without conclusive evidence it is reasonable to alter therapy rather than have a patient continue to take a drug that a test shows is ineffective.
Dr. Mark A. Goodman, president of Cardiovascular Medical Associates in Garden City, N.Y., said he tested all his patients and found that 20 to 25 percent were aspirin resistant. For those people, Dr. Goodman said, he first tries a higher dose, because that is the least expensive alternative.
If that does not work - and it usually does not - he prescribes another anticlotting drug, Plavix, that can cost $3 or more a day, compared with pennies a day for aspirin.
Aspirin resistance could be one reason many people continue to have heart attacks and strokes even though they take aspirin. But, experts said, it is quite likely that some people have heart attacks or strokes even if aspirin is providing the desired anticlotting effect.
It is widely believed that the main way aspirin provides cardiovascular protection is by blocking the ability of platelets in the blood to stick together, a vital step in forming clots that can lead to a heart attack or stroke. Aspirin blocks an enzyme, cyclo-oxygenase, that is involved in producing thromboxane, a substance that induces platelets to clump.
The standard test of how readily platelets clump is called aggregometry. It is usually performed in a specialized laboratory and can take two to three hours.