After reading all I could get my hands on, I did not think there was anywhere near enough published information to make a clear choice among the different valves. The newer ones sound promising but do not have enough experience data to say whether their design features will really pan out to be advantages or have perhaps some unintended effects. I decided to trust the opinion of my surgeon. He had a rather strong preference. I'm a very skeptical person who suspects that most people, even supposed experts, are unjustifiably biased, but he struck me as one of the smartest people I had ever met and one of the most respected in his field. For me to think that I could possibly in a few months of casual study become better informed than he had in 30 years of being involved directly in valve surgery at all levels, was rather ludicrous. So, I went with his preference. That is not to say he doesn't use other valves, depending on the situation. I got a St. Judes. A couple of weeks later he installed a Carbomedics valve in another member here. Anyway, try to find a surgeon you can trust, seek his advice and ask as many questions as you can to him about why he recommends what he does. Most surgeons have preferences. Some instead choose to stay out of the choice-making, regarding it as a "personal" choice you need to make. Still, your surgeon should be your best information source or I would look for another surgeon.
Finding the best surgeon for you is a challenge. For informational purposes only, I went to the best academic center for OHS in our area and arranged an appointment with their most experienced valve surgeon. I was not necessarily intending to have my surgery there. I really just wanted information. My local cardiologist was not planning on sending me there, but was probably going to recommend a local community surgeon and hospital. She said she refers "more complicated" cases to the academic centers. I believe my case turned out to be more complicated than she appreciated, and I am rather glad that I connected with the academic center and surgeon on my own and had my surgery done there. It may have turned out just as well done locally, but I'll never know that for sure. Although AVR has become rather routine surgery, I had a quite a bit of my aortic arch replaced as well, which requited hypothermic total circulatory arrest with retrograde cerebral perfusion. I don't think I'd be comfortable with that except in the most experienced hands.
Bill