confused about stress test

Valve Replacement Forums

Help Support Valve Replacement Forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
M

maka

I?m totally confused about ?stress tests?. By the replies of some of you, it seems a stress test could be dangerous and I believe some have even indicated they don?t feel well for some time afterwards. (Please my apologies, I can?t find the posts that I read earlier where I got that impression).
If I?m correct on the above, why should an individual be concerned about having a stress test?
What?s the difference from regular exercising in a treadmill and a stress test? Some individuals at this forum seem to go for several miles ( I can merely walk one in the treadmill :eek: )
Are more than one kind of stress test? Are stress tests necessary before you start cardio rehab at a medical facility? Has anyone had a bad experience with stress tests?
Thanks
 
My former cardio wanted me to have an exercise stress test just a few months after surgery, and as a requirement for entering cardiac rehab. To me that was contrary to common sense. A stress test pushes you to the limit of your stamina so the medical people can record your body's responses. I was not ready to undergo such a test and so I said no. I got into cardiac rehab anyway and benefitted from it. A stress test may be helpful in detecting heart problems in persons who appear to be problem-free, but it makes no sense to me to put surgical survivors through that.
 
I had one last week.

I had one last week.

Yes, it was a requirement for my cardia rehab as well. My card tried to get me out of it but the hospital wouldn't take me if I didn't. It was more a point of incovenience to me. The hopsital (for cardiac rehab) was close to work but they wanted a consultation as well as a stress test which meant 2 appointments before I ever got in to the program, which would be month out. Anyway, I did both in the same visit and they squeezed me in.

My card said it was okay to do the stress test as I argued the same point as you did. The stress test isn't bad, once you reach your target heart rate you stop. It's a 9:00 minute test on a tread mill with 3 different levels ,every 3 minutes each level gets harder. However, you can stop when you feel like it. The card or nurse constantly ask how you are feeling as you walk. I reached my target heart rate right at the 9:00 minute mark :) The reason they do the stress test is to see where they should start you in cardiac rehab. It's not as bad as it sounds. I had the same concerns as you.

Having said this, I'm assuming that all stress tests are the same.
 
my stress echo

my stress echo

was to determine if my regurgitation was worse with exercise.
It was not a difficult test and I didn't feel bad from it. It actually helped them to determine that exercise did not make the situation worse.
Altho I didn't last very long on the treadmill, b/c I was way too short of breath!
 
You are pre-surgery. Some of these responses are post-surgery.

I'm the 52 year old, almost 5 weeks post surgery. I have not been good about exercise over the years. I am tall and overweight. My exercise tolerance is low. My stress test 3 years ago did not last long, and it seemed somewhat inconclusive as I got so out of breath and they couldn't really tell if it was the valve or just me. Also, I am large breasted and so the scans they did were mostly blocked by the breast tissue.

For the nuclear stress test (the nuclear part being an insisted on part by my internist who is young and swears that female patienst get no benefit from a normal, male designed, non-nuclear treadmill stress test) I went in fasting. They either injected me, or had me drink (sorry, don't remember) something then did an ultrasound (or xray) of my heart while I was lying very still. The radioactive isotope thingy's show up and give them some kind of reading. Then you go onto a treadmill on which they raise the slope as you go. My slope was raised very quickly and since my only symptom at the time was breathlessness at the top of the stairs, it obviously got to me quite soon and I was done. All the while, they have you hooked up to monitors and they ask you every 10 seconds how you're feeling, any pain, any dizziness? So, for me, I was like dying, feeling, ready to explode, terrified of passing out (first cardio's words, "well you never want to get to the point of passing out...then it becomes an emergency" running through my brain like a mantra) and yet they seemed to think I would KNOW it if I was going to be dizzy and pass out. Anyway. They pushed me abit and then it was done. I had another "hit" of the radioactive stuff, and they quickly took another comparative "photo" of me. I waited (to be sure I was not ill, or woozy), ate, and they let me go home.

I think what we are suggesting is that you try to get a clear picture of why the cardio wants this done. There is risk. They could set off an incident. But so could a car accident and I bet you drive all over the place! I was also nervous about having an angiogram. There is risk with those. But I had a surgery date by then, so it was all part of that process. For you this is a diagnostic tool, for what??? to tell you that you have stenosis? To tell you if you tolerate exercise? You know that already. Is it so that they can put off surgery for awhile?? Is it to set you up on an exercise program to put off surgery? Why does he want this? What info does he need to gain from this? What is he looking for?

You might ask him about the measurements from the TEE. I know that echo measurements are subject to variation depending on the tech's reading and other factors. I think the TEE is remarkably clear and precise. The angiogram is also a very true measure of valve size. Again, ask him at what size he recommends the surgeon.

My cardios thought I should wait as long as I possibly could, safely, before getting the valve replaced. Your life isn't being impacted, your quality of life...you have few symptoms. By waiting years (if this is possible) you will have available to you, far more choices in replacement. Technology is improving leaps and bounds. Have you begun to think about your choice of valve? That is a very important choice. At your age, it is a tough choice. If you were in your 60's it would be an easier choice.

We tried to ward off the stenosis with medicine. It did not work. In fact, personally, I think it sped thing up!! Or it was just my will.....I was very impatient to have the surgery because the uncertainty of my own valve was stressful.

I am going to go off on several tangents and I don't want to confuse things here. We can be confusing, here on the forum, and I'm sorry for that. I think overall, what we are all about here is advising people to really get the facts. Sometimes it's very hard to know the questions. I hope I have helped you to formulate some questions. Then you get your answers and weigh them against your own beliefs, understandings and expectations.

Keep asking!!! We're here 24/7. :)

Marguerite
 
Mine was to determine what I could do, which would help my cardio decide for sure about when to do the PVR. (Actually, she had pretty much decided I needed it within 6 months, and the test confirmed it.)

I got up to my peak in less than 6 minutes and 30 seconds. I can do 59% of what a healthy woman my age and size can do. Yep, surgery this summer.

I can't wait to see how my treadmill test is after I've recovered from OHS!
 
I haven't had surgery yet, but recently to diagnose what was going on with my valve, my cardio had me do a stress echo (echo first, then treadmill, then echo again), but my valve looked so bad that he didn't want to risk putting me on the treadmill.

I guess it's up to your doctor's discretion, but if you don't feel comfortable doing do, tell him/her.

Hope that helps--

Debi (debster913)
 
To get in rehab, ...

To get in rehab, ...

...I had a cardiopulmonary stress test. It is not like the regular stress test that my friends have had. You walk on a treadmill with somethimg blocking your nose so you have to breath through your mouth the whole time. it tests something to do with how your lungs use oxygen. My legs got too tired to go on way before I got out of breath. here is part of an article explaining it.

"A cardiopulmonary stress test (CPX test) is a special treadmill test. This test takes an ECG and measures how your lungs work while you exercise.An exercise physiologist, a doctor and a nurse will be present during your test.

For the test, ECG wires will be attached to your chest for an electrocardiogram of your heart. You will breathe into a breath analyzer that measures the gas exchange in your lungs. An oximeter will be placed on your finger to determine how much oxygen is in your blood while you exercise. Your blood pressure and pulse will be taken during the test.

You will start out by walking slowly on the treadmill. You will be asked to gradually increase your speed and incline. You can stop the test at any time. If at any point during the test you feel as if you have had enough, give the ?thumbs down? signal to the exercise physiologist and doctor. They will slow down the treadmill and stop the test.

The results of the test will help your doctor choose a target heart rate for you to reach when you exercise and decide the best exercise for you."
 
That's exactly what my stress test was, Praline. Thanks for finding that information!
 
Thank you all so much for the replies. To clarify the reason for my question, here is my story. I had mitral valve repair in August. I live in NY where my ?main? doctors are located but spend winters in Fl. I have a cardio doctor in FL to have medical records and a reference in case I ever need medical assistance. I asked the doctor in FL about cardio rehab and he told me I needed to take a stress test first as some of you have said. BUT, it required some kind of dye to be injected. I?m allergy to some things and I have heard of bad experiences about stress tests so I told him, no thanks.
I?ve had a couple of tests prior to surgery at a cardio?s office (not the one I?m seeing now) All I did was to walk in the treadmill while he looked at a monitor (I was wired like for a EKG) But no injections. He never pushed me too hard and don?t remember how long I lasted but it was not very long...something like stage 2 or 3
I?m seeing my cardio in NY this Wednesday and will ask her about cardio rehab.and what she thinks about it. I?m not very exercise oriented The main reason is to know what I can do and what I can?t. Not even sure whether I?ll go or not as the place I like near the hospital I was operated is about 1 ½ hr from home. Your comments will help me to ask more questions in case she says I need to take a stress test. I can see that not all stress test are the same. I guess I don?t mind walking the treadmill but will be concerned about anything that need to be injected into my system
 
Back
Top